Further, there is little research on how environmental discount rates differ from monetary. Retaining the approach of the original edition, the newest iteration features global warming as the framing example for a comprehensive look at environmental economics. We develop a simple model of the economy that illustrates how changes in crucial technology and preference parameters may affect both the discount rate and the. Recent journal of environmental economics and management articles recently published articles from journal of environmental economics and management. The omb, in setting the discount rate at 7 percent, notes that this rate approximates the marginal pretax rate of return on an average investment in the private. Simply to treat the future as better off, however, is to commit an ecological fallacy. I sustainable development, growth theory, environmental kuznets curves, and discounting roger perman, david i. Resolving the paradoxes of discounting in environmental. Contents lists available at sciencedirect journal of. Discounting, climate change, and the ecological fallacy matthew rendall discounting future costs and bene. Mar 30, 2010 many environmental economists, including me, are troubled by the use of almost any discount rate greater than zero to calculate the current worth of values future benefits and harms that will occur more than a generation from now an issue of especially importance in climate economics. Recent journal of environmental economics and management. Todays environmental experts have a wide range of tools at their disposal for the design and evaluation of local, state, regional, and national policies. Therefore, the marginal utility or incremental satisfaction they will get from the third, fourth or fifth car will be lower and lower.
Overview of discounting and time preference topics covered on this web page. Understanding individual discounting behavior of future costs and benefits is critical for designing environmental policy. The economics of climate change and the theory of discounting. Pdf behavioural economics, hyperbolic discounting and. Empirical results from behavioural economics provide a reminder that human behaviour is contextdependent, implying that policy.
Discounting, climate change, and the ecological fallacy. Many environmental economists, including me, are troubled by the use of almost any discount rate greater than zero to calculate the current worth of values future benefits and harms that will occur more than a generation from now an issue of especially importance in climate economics. Climate change has morphed from an environmental problem into a challenge to civilization itself. Received 8 december 2009 available online 20 april 2010 keywords. International society for ecological economics internet encyclopaedia of ecological economics discounting the future cedric philibert international energy agency, energy and environment division june 2003 introduction discounting is probably one of the most disputed issues in ecological economics. Discounting and relative prices in assessing future environmental.
Discounting background reading in our textbooks very short. Sustainable development, growth theory, environmental. They incorporate recent advances in theoretical and applied work in the field of environmental economics. Extended coverage on economywide modelling, valuing the environment, the practice and ethics of discounting and climate change. The economics climate change university of california. David maddison is professor of economics at the university of birmingham. Pdf the endowment effect, discounting and the environment. International society for ecological economics internet. The application of discounting to environmentalpolicy evaluation is controversial, partly because of misunderstanding outside the economics community of. Background paper, resolving the paradoxes of discounting in recalibrating the law of. Importantly, however, although individuals may differ with regard to delay discounting in the form or degree to which the delayed results depreciate, delay discounting must be considered as a behavioral tendency that can change under different environmental or pharmacological conditions rather than as a fixed trait.
These changes in relative prices may more than counteract the effect of discounting, so that the net effect is higher rather than lower values. Sustainable environmental and natural resource economics. Standard costbenefit analysis methods involve estimating the dollar values of costs. However, ramsey did not take environmental considerations and resource exhaustion into. Guidelines for preparing economic analyses environmental. As co2 levels have continued to rise, the 8th edition of this book is now more relevant than ever. The harvard environmental economics program the harvard environmental economics program develops innovative answers to todays complex environmental issues, by providing a venue to bring together faculty and graduate students from across the university engaged in research, teaching, and outreach in environmental and natural. Review of environmental economics and policy, volume 2, issue 1, winter 2008. In a modern textbook of environmental and natural resource economics it is stated as follows.
Yue ma is associate professor in economics, lingnan university, hong kong, and adjunct professor of lingnan college, zhongshan university, china. Sustainable development, growth theory, environmental kuznets. Oct 17, 2002 the application of discounting to environmental policy evaluation is controversial, partly because of misunderstanding outside the economics community of what discounting actually does, which is. Discounting behavior and environmental decisions economics. Epas guidelines for preparing economic analyses establish a sound scientific framework for performing economic analyses of environmental regulations and policies. Discount rates for environmental benefits occurring in the. Discounting is the process of determining the present value of a payment or a stream of payments that is to be received in the future. In this paper i offer a fairly complete account of the idea of social discount rates as applied to public policy analysis. This part introduces economic tools to address environmental. Costbenefit analysis cba is the primary tool that economists em.
Discounting of future benefits of environmental benefits is examined in detail for the importance it has in climate change policy. Ecological economics for their intellectual contributions and the community of scholarship and support they provide. A notable exception is heal 2005 who discusses a form of multiplicatively separable discounting logarithmic discounting and praises its attractive properties p. New chapter on trade and the environment, and for the first time, the text examines the economics of happiness. Should a welltrained mineral economist take a course on environmental economics, which uses a text such as this, as part of his or her training. As such, environmental economics can work well as a tool for analyzing policy in the short term. This is an advanced undergraduate textbook, assuming the reader to have a good knowledge of intermediate. What this implies for discounting future environmental benefits may then depend critically on whether environmental quality is merely a factor of production of material consumption, or whether it. The fifth section discusses the reverse side of the discounting issue that of valuing environmental. Journal of environmental economics and management 60 2010 1. Environmental economics discounting and time preference. When weighing the benefits and costs of coastal restoration projects and other environmental management programs, the selection of a discount rate is a key consideration and often a source of controversy. Section 3 uses harris and laibson 2001s heuristic method to derive the euler equation in a stockpollutant model. Resolving the paradoxes of discounting in environmental decisions.
Discount rates for environmental benefits occurring in the fardistant future. Discounting behavior and environmental decisions richard t. Given the time value of money, a dollar is worth more today. His main fields of research are international environmental economics, the theory of public goods, intertemporal evaluation and discounting, social protection and distribution policy and the links between economics and ethics. Economics is an important tool for making decisions about the use. Environmental economics takes into consideration issues such as the conservation and valuation of natural resources, pollution control, waste management and recycling, and the efficient creation of emission standards. Unesco eolss sample chapters economics interactions with other disciplines vol. This paper is a step towards providing that analysis. The concept of discounting is central to economics, since it allows effects occurring at different future times to be.
The concept of discounting and present value are based on a type. I show that those rates are neither ethical primitives nor observables as market rates of return on investment, but that they ought instead to be derived from economic forecasts and societys conception of distributive justice concerning the allocation of goods and. An introduction to environmental economics and economic concepts unit information 3. A number of relatively recent textbooks in environmental economics suggest that general economic theory provides a clear and wellestablished.
There exists a certain biophysical time and impactlag, that. Stern encyclopedia of life support systems eolss however, diminishing returns to capital shown by the decreasing rate of increase of the. Click download or read online button to get environmental economics a textbook book now. Discounting is justified by the expectation of economic growth. Many of these tools were developed at rff, and the organizations contribution to the field of environmental economics remains one of its greatest legacies. Current best practice in environmental costbenefit analysis reflects, in its turn, an array of conceptual and empirical developments primarily in environmental economics but also in other fields of economic inquiry such as health economics. This includes issues relating to markets as well as to public policy. Environmental economics a textbook download ebook pdf, epub. The basic idea is that scarce resources should be allocated to their most valued uses. This monograph certainly provides an excellent appreciation of the elements of environmental economics. His major research interests are international banking and finance, as well as environmental economics for developing countries.
The economics of climate change c 175 the economics of climate change c 175. The economics climate change department of agricultural. Timeconsistent hyperbolic discounting got so far relatively little attention in environmental economics. We especially wish to acknowledge robert costanza, and the faculty at the gund institute for ecological economics at the university of vermont, as well as our colleagues at the university of maryland school of public affairs. Environmental economics a textbook download ebook pdf.
Environmental economics has developed as a branch of economics that is concerned with the economic analysis of the causes and the nature of environmental problems and their solutions. Hyperbolic discounting and the timeconsistent solution of. Carson university of california san diego and university of technology, sydney brigitte roth tran university of california san diego discounting plays a major role in the life cycle of environmental and natural resource policies. Discounting riskadjusted distant future gamma discounting climate change abstract it is widely recognized that the economics of distantfuture events, like climate change. Background reading in our textbooks very short kolstad, charles d. The gamma pdf combines beautifully with exponential discounting to create a usable expression for the certaintyequivalent discount factor, which is. February 3, 2009 as is often the case in economics, an obscure and often dullsounding issue, can quickly get into some deep moral questions.
Environmental economics is often interpreted to include resource economics. Unfortunately there are few if any applications directly to the minerals and energy sector. Foundations of environmental economics wolfgang buchholz. Department of economics, harvard university, usa article info article history. It works well as a tool for analyzing environmental policy given clear, exogenously defined costs and benefits. Easy to follow, new two colour textdesign and improved pedagogical features for enhanced readability and quick reference. Stern encyclopedia of life support systems eolss for economic growth and sustainable economic development are considered. Behavioural economics, hyperbolic discounting and environmental policy article pdf available in environmental and resource economics 462. In most cases, it truly takes a long time for any environmental project to take effect and make an impact so that the muchdesired benefits can be realised and distributed among society.
Kotchen when economics is normativemeaning that the objective is to make a policy recommendation the evaluative criteria is economic efficiency. Social discounting, the type of discounting discussed in this chapter, is discounting from. In many standard economics textbooks the term resources is used. In economic terms, this concern may be related to those services of the environment that are consumed directly rather than being employed in production, and to. Policy analysts typically presume that future payoffs should be discounted relative to present ones, and that this discounting should proceed at the same rate for all goods and all periods. Rubbelke is professor of economics at technische universitat bergakademie freiberg. Empirical results from behavioural economics provide a reminder that human behaviour is contextdependent, implying that policy may go awry if based upon models of behaviour which are inappropriate to the contexts in which decisions are made. Although there is some empirical evidence of hyperbolic discounting, others have found that exponential discounting is more accurate when behavioral factors are properly considered. Economics, natural and environmental resources if economics is generally understood as the study of the allocation of limited resources to satisfy human wants and desires, then it is first of all necessary to define the term resources. Pdf the discount rate in environmental costbenefit analysis. This site is like a library, use search box in the widget to get ebook that you want. A distinction is sometimes made between resource and environmental economics, where the latter. Properly applied, discounting can tell us how much future benefits and costs are worth today.
1153 256 250 966 1379 901 318 115 1257 1252 1422 391 196 72 136 161 1313 901 887 1268 1449 3 1359 1495 523 673 598